After reading both The Memoir and the Memoirist and The Liar's Club, I've noticed a few similarities between the two so far. Mary Karr is a professor of Literature at Syracuse University as Thomas Larson taught how to write memoirs for a small, interested class (as far as I know). It's very evident that they are highly educated by the vocabulary that is used such as Karr's words of "pseudo-demonic" and "segue", and Larson's "monolithic" and "elan." But Karr used much more intriguing vocabulary that is more relatable to how people may have talked in Texas like "mulligrubs" and "guarangoddamntee," especially; the words are amusing and get the reader into the story.
Focusing on The Liar's Club, this is the actual memoir of a time in Mary's life. She uses incredible detail to conveigh the experience as she remembers it. As Daddy tells his story of running away from home there's a point that she calls "the turning point. Daddy cocks his head at everybody to savor it. . . The domino tiles stop their endless clicking. The cigar smoke might even seem to quit winding around on itself for a minute. Nobody so much as takes a drink." Karr looks up to her father at that young age, saying that he was a talented storyteller and the other men of the so called Liar's Club thought so to when they would all turn to silence as he started a story.
Karr was always "spoiled" by her father as Larson was by his own father when he was young. It was interesting to me because I'm the only daughter amongst three brothers, so I definitely was spoiled myself. Thomas focused more on the psychological aspect of writing about real life, which was interesting. He talked about Julie who was "surprised by what she didn't know or half-remembered" which was related to Karr's one memory that she thought so crystal clear that she had to write in present tense; only that one memory.
Tuesday, January 6, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I like that you talked about the vocabulary used in "Liars' Club". I didn't think about mentioning it, but it is kind of important because it adds to the authenticity of the story.You did go into a lot more detail about the "Liars' Club" than about "The Memoir and the Memoirist." Also I like that you drew similarities between the two books to start off.
ReplyDeleteThat was an interesting point you made about the vocabulary usage amongst the two writers. I also noticed the southern twang while reading Karr's novel and it also made me feel more engaged in the reading. It was also a good call on noticing the "Turning point." I also like how you tied the final paragraph into personal traits toward your own life.
ReplyDeleteRebecca,
ReplyDeleteYour real strength here is the fact that you use such wonderful examples and focus even on individual words. That's the stuff great analysis is made of.
Good connections between The Liars' Club and Memoir. Later, we'll read the chapter in Larson that's primarily about The Liars' Club.
Good start. Keep reading over these and revising.
I look forward to your work this quarter.